By Samuel Hupp, Office of Peacebuilding and Policy
The process of registering men for military drafts, known as the Selective Service System (SSS) in the United States, has been a longtime obstacle for those who refuse to participate in organized conflict and a focus for many anti-war advocates.
Although formalized options allowing conscientious objection have existed in the form of alternative service since the enactment of the modern SSS in 1917, many potential draftees have entirely avoided registration in the system for a variety of reasons.
However, in the past year, non-registration has received greater attention from both elected officials and the Department of Defense, with efforts being made to reach near-universal Selective Service registration rates. Despite plans to fully automate registration beginning on Dec. 18, 2026, the proposed system was rescinded by the SSS in July.
Since then, the issue has remained unresolved, and the future for draft resisters has remained uncertain.
The Selective Service System
Since 1917, military conscription in the US has operated under the Selective Service System. The SSS is an executive agency separate from the Department of Defense, and it has been activated through both wartime and peacetime drafts. After large-scale public disapproval of drafting policies during the Vietnam War, the US military moved to an all-volunteer force. For most of the 1970s, even registration wasn’t required of the general public but this was reverted in 1980 under President Carter. Since then, young men have been legally obligated to self-register with the SSS, in many states while obtaining driver’s licenses.
SSS registration often is supported through schools with standalone applications made available to students, who have been warned that they will face legal risk and exclusion from some state student programs. Additionally, the registration process is “automatic” in 44 states, meaning that it is integrated as a part of the filing process for drivers’ licenses or personal IDs. However, this currently requires consent, either through a standard waiver, or by providing an opt-out form to explicitly avoid registration. This varies by state, with some assuming consent as the default.
Through these options, draft resistance is possible but registration rates by age 18 remain over 90 percent nationally, according to the US Army blog. States that do not tie registration to application for licenses and IDs see much lower rates of registration; the same source cites Californian compliance with selective service at 56 percent of 18-year-olds. These numbers only increase by age group, as there are no methods of de-registration apart from normal qualified exemptions from military service.
Although non-registration remains a felony under US law, no draft resisters have been prosecuted since the 1980s. Violators of mandatory registration rarely are financially pursued, leaving the law practically unenforced.
The bill
In December 2025, Congress voted to close the loopholes that allowed for non-registration, moving to implement the automatic registration of all eligible male citizens. As Section 535 of the Fiscal Year 2026 National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA), this mandate empowered the SSS to reform the current system. The vote, which marked the 65th consecutive passing of an annual NDAA, received bipartisan support.
The bill, signed into law by President Trump, applied not only to US citizens ages 18-25 but also to every male of those ages present on US soil (with the exception of those on non-immigrant visas). This means that when possible, the SSS would register asylum seekers, green card holders, and undocumented immigrants.
While the act called for this change, the implementation was left entirely to the SSS, which was given 1 year for full execution. By spring of the next year, it was announced that a plan had been drafted and submitted for review.
The stall
The plan, which had been submitted in early 2026, was suddenly rescinded in July 2026 before it was available for public review. No reason was given by the SSS. With no alternative advanced since, the plan to automate registration remains unfulfilled as the Dec. 18 deadline approaches.
What’s next?
Unless the deadline is extended, any reworked plans to automate registration will suffer from a sharply decreased period of review. Although the added pressure may sway elected officials to approve a proposed method, legislative attitudes towards defense policy have shifted over the course of the year. While the 2026 NDAA received moderate bipartisan support, the current war against Iran has soured attitudes towards increased militarization especially among Democrats. This, combined with a wave of incoming Democratic legislators from this year’s elections, could prompt elected officials to delay the implementation of a new Selective Service System.
In response to this uncertainty, draft resisters and anti-war activists have some courses of action:
— The first and most obvious is to lobby for legislative delays or changes to the Dec. 18 deadline. High levels of turnover in both the House of Representatives and Senate pose a unique opportunity for advocates.
— At the individual level, young men who oppose conscription can create portfolios to highlight personal opposition to militarized conflict. While a draft is highly unlikely any time in the near future, conscientious objector status is best argued through a personal history of public statements and writings; taking a stance now in preservable ways such as letters to the editor, mail correspondence, and discussion groups can strengthen one’s case to qualify as a conscientious objector in a situation of conscription.
Webinar
On Dec. 15, just days before the Dec. 18 deadline imposed by Congress, the Church of the Brethren and On Earth Peace are offering a webinar at 8 p.m. (Eastern time), led by On Earth Peace and the denominational Office of Peacebuilding and Policy. The program, led by Ewan Benjamin and Sam Hupp, welcomes all, seeking to include youth, young adults, faith leaders, and interested community members. Register for the webinar
— Samuel Hupp is a Brethren Volunteer Service worker serving at the Church of the Brethren Office of Peacebuilding and Policy.
#MissionAndMinistryBoard #StrategicPlan #RacialJustice #LoveOurNeighbors #Discipleship #NewTestamentGiving
———-
Find more Church of the Brethren news:
- The uncertain future of universal Selective Service
- Webinar will provide information about automatic draft registration, conscientious objection
- El seminario web proporcionará información sobre el registro automático de reclutamiento y la objeción de conciencia.
- Webinè a pral bay enfòmasyon sou enskripsyon otomatik pou rekritman, objeksyon konsyans.
- Ventures to offer courses on ‘Speed Dating the Bible’ and ‘Leading Through the Storm’